'We were miles off': Rennie owns All Blacks' record loss
By Liam Napier at Twickenham
As the unwanted history and pressure piles on the All Blacks, it’s difficult to see an immediate solution in sight.
A poor performance at Twickenham – among the worst from the All Blacks in recent memory – casts a dark cloud over Dave Rennie’s first season at the helm.
Such a bleak loss, the third largest in All Blacks history behind Scott Robertson’s (33 points) against South Africa Wellington last year, and Ian Foster’s (28 points) to the Springboks at Twickenham before the 2023 World Cup, sparks widespread questions of Rennie’s regime.
The All Blacks had every reason to front against England.
Last week’s first loss to Wales in 73 years should have evoked a reaction.
There were individual accolades, including Beauden Barrett’s 150th test milestone, and a place in the Nations Championship final at stake. And, yet, the All Blacks summoned easily their worst performance of the year.
Everything went wrong at Twickenham. From the flat start to the ropy defence that conceded 12 line breaks, the shaky lineout, the 16 turnovers and being completely dominated at the collisions to make a mess of the breakdown, there are a litany of issues for the All Blacks to solve.
A record defeat to England and the largest loss to any northern hemisphere nation underlines the scale of the setback.

Dave Rennie: "We were miles off tonight." Photo / Photosport
“We were miles off tonight,” Rennie conceded after the 37-12 loss. “We lacked the intensity and accuracy to be competitive at this level. England were very good.
“We gave them too many opportunities down our end to hurt us and couldn’t get any continuity in our game going.
“It’s disappointing. We’ll spend the next couple of days trying to work out why. I felt the prep was good. There’s many motivating factors to perform well tonight but we were well short.
“There’s no lack of effort and heart. With a team like England you’ve got to apply pressure. Most of the footy we played at our end. At half time we’d made 133 tackles to their 39. Maybe that told in the end. You look at the stats, we got well beaten in just about every number.”
Five-tries-to-two doesn’t reflect England’s dominance. After watching the All Blacks slump to five losses to equal their worst season of the professional era, Rennie accepted his role in the latest defeat.
As England toasted their first successive wins over the All Blacks since 2002-2003, parallels will be drawn to last November when Robertson’s tenure officially unravelled at the same venue.
“As head coach you’re responsible for the results. I’m not going to hide from the fact we weren’t good enough tonight. I’m a big part of that,” Rennie said.
“If you look at last week’s performance, the only thing we lacked was finishing. There was a lot of good footy played but we were miles off tonight. It’s clearly not where we want to be.
“Last week, I felt we let the country down. It was a way worse performance tonight. The guys are hurting.”

All Blacks captain Codie Taylor and coach Dave Rennie face the press after defeat a Twickenham. Photo / Photosport
All Blacks captain Codie Taylor lamented his role in the lineout that operated at a lowly 67%.
“Coming here, you always know England will come out with an intensity. We were our worst enemy in terms of our accuracy and holding onto the ball. If you can’t do that against England it’s pretty hard,” Taylor said. “We were always chasing the game. We won’t make any excuses. We’ll own it. We weren’t good enough out there.
“There’s no hiding from the fact we need to be better, both personally and as a forward pack. We thought we had a good plan but plans don’t always come out.”
In the wake of successive defeats to Wales and England, Rennie won’t be alone in facing scrutiny. The spotlight is on forwards coach Neil Barnes and defence coach Tana Umaga as their respective areas falter.
Depth will be questioned, too, as a torrid season forces the All Blacks to dig deep into their playing ranks.
“I’ve got no doubt about the quality of the people we have,” Rennie said. “It was a poor night but from a playing perspective we’ve got excellent men and staffing wise we’ve got a great group. Tonight’s result is disappointing but it hasn’t changed my view on the quality of the people.”
Rennie refused to attribute any blame for the sharp downturn on the emotional toll following the sudden death of the All Blacks long-serving head of security Logan Cadwallader two weeks ago, or fatigue from a gruelling season that’s claimed the likes of Ardie Savea, Luke Jacobson, Quinn Tupaea, Caleb Clarke among others.
“I don’t want to go there. Someone outside mentioned it being a massive year. Our mindset is that we had two big games left in the year. We were really focused on that. I felt we prepared well. That’s for others to judge.”
The Springboks losing bonus point against Ireland in Dublin is enough to propel them into the Nations Championship final on superior points differential – and force the All Blacks into a likely rematch with England at Twickenham next weekend.
“It’s a really proud group. We’re all incredibly disappointed. We’ll want to make amends for that. Getting the guys up for one last crack won’t be difficult.”
Liam Napier is a Senior Sports Journalist and Rugby Correspondent for the New Zealand Herald. He is a co-host of the Rugby Direct podcast.
Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you