ZB ZB
Election 2026
Sport
Live now
Start time
Playing for
End time
Listen live
Listen to Newstalk ZB
Up next
Listen live on
ZB

Aviation officer sacked for reading book, having eyes closed during security X-rays

Author
Brianna McIlraith,
Publish Date
Sun, 22 Nov 2026, 1:49pm

An experienced Civil Aviation Authority security officer tasked with checking bags going through security was seen reading a book, instead of looking at X-ray images.

They were also seen closing their eyes at the screening desk, doing one-armed pat-down and not undertaking ballistic testing.

The security officer lost their job and took their case to the Employment Relations Authority, claiming they were unjustifiably dismissed and disadvantaged because the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) refused to offer further training as it did after a similar issue months earlier.

But authority member Claire English found there were “significant failings” by the employee to perform their core duties.

In a recently released decision, English said the employee’s own evidence that they had effectively already been given a “second chance for the same conduct meant they understood what was required of them.

Employee seen working with their eyes closed

The employee had worked for the CAA for seven years.

On January 17, 2025, they were rostered to perform non-passenger screening.

Non-passenger screening checks airport workers, contractors, visitors, vehicles and items entering or operating within security-enhanced areas to prevent weapons, explosives and prohibited items from reaching aircraft.

During the shift, a team leader observed them standing some distance from the screening machines and leaving the belt running while performing other activities.

Another manager saw them not assessing X-ray imaging and performing other tasks while bags were being screened.

The employee did not perform ballistics testing under CAA procedures and performed pat-downs with one hand only and without the level of pressure required.

In addition, they were observed reading a book and being in a resting position with their head down on the counter and eyes closed.

Concerns were raised with the employee, and they were placed on paid special leave and later paid suspension.

During the CAA investigation, they apologised and said they had been tired and unable to concentrate at the time.

The employee told the CAA that when they were unable to see items that passed through the X-ray scanner, they rewound the footage afterwards and security screening was still provided, although they accepted they had not followed screening procedures.

Medical information provided by the employee to the CAA advised that medical issues could have contributed to their inattention on the day in question, but could not be cited as the only cause, and they were fully fit to work.

The employee told the CAA that a performance improvement plan with wellbeing support would be an appropriate outcome, but on February 23, 2026, the employee was dismissed.

Screening taken with ‘utmost seriousness’ by CAA

The employee told the authority that on the day in question, they were rostered to work an early morning shift and as a result, they were tired.

This was coupled with non-compliance with prescribed medication, which they said impacted their ability to perform that day.

The employee accepted they did not perform ballistics testing as required that day and only performed pat-downs with one hand; however, they used sufficient pressure.

The decision said they accepted they did not stop the X-ray conveyor belt when performing other tasks requiring them to step away from the screen displaying the results; however, they said that on those occasions, they would rewind the footage shortly thereafter so in their view screening of those items was still provided, just not in accordance with CAA procedure.

CAA did not accept this, taking the view that there were multiple occasions when the employee did not rewind the belt, or did not do so until after persons had passed through the screening point.

The CAA told the authority that security screening was a matter it takes with the utmost seriousness.

“It is a matter of both national and personal safety and security and the risks of screening failure are obvious, well-known, and potentially deeply harmful,” the decision said.

It said it provides ongoing training and practical support to its staff, and the employee was a properly trained and experienced staff member who had worked successfully in the role for seven years and knew what was expected of them.

Employee’s second chance

The employee submitted that CAA should have entered into a performance improvement process because this was a performance issue capable of being rectified, and CAA’s disciplinary processes generally required some engagement or warning before dismissal.

This was because months earlier, they had been required to speak with their manager about a similar issue, where they had not been adequately viewing the X-ray screening machine in a passenger-facing role, including not looking at the screen and reading a book while on duty.

They accepted they had not followed CAA’s screening process.

“In any event, [the employee’s] own evidence is that they had effectively already been given a ‘second chance’ for the same conduct,” English said.

“That being the case, there can be no reasonable criticism of CAA for concluding that [the employee] understood what was required of them.”

English found that the claims of unjustified dismissal and unjustified disadvantage were not made out. No orders were made.

A CAA spokesperson said it could not comment on the employment case, but it was important the organisation upholds trust and confidence in its services and staff to perform that role.

Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you

Live
Listen on iHeartRadio
Currently On Air
Listen on iHeartRadio