ZB ZB
Election 2026
Sport
Live now
Start time
Playing for
End time
Listen live
Listen to Newstalk ZB
Up next
Listen live on
ZB

'Radio silence': Personal struggles no defence for lawyers' client neglect

Author
Tara Shaskey,
Publish Date
Sun, 22 Nov 2026, 2:13pm
Two lawyers have been disciplined after clients were left without support while the lawyers faced personal difficulties. Photo / Getty Images

Overwhelming workload, personal crisis, mental health struggles and family tragedy may explain lawyers’ “radio silence”, but they do not excuse leaving clients “unsupported and vulnerable”.

That was the message in two recent disciplinary decisions involving lawyers who faced personal challenges but were found to have breached their professional obligations after failing to communicate with clients and help them find alternative legal representation.

In separate decisions, New Zealand Law Society standards committees found both lawyers, who were not named, had engaged in unsatisfactory conduct.

One case involved a family lawyer who left her client without updates, her file or assistance in finding a new lawyer while winding up her practice and dealing with mental health difficulties.

The other concerned a lawyer who failed to respond to a client for months before terminating a retainer following the death of a family member.

While both decisions acknowledged the personal difficulties the lawyers faced, they stressed those circumstances did not relieve them of their professional obligations to clients.

In each case, the lawyer was found to have failed in their obligations to communicate effectively and assist clients when ending a retainer.

Client left ‘unsupported and vulnerable’

The family lawyer had acted for a woman involved in a family law dispute, including proceedings in the Court of Appeal.

The client complained that communication throughout the appeal process was poor and that she was left uncertain whether the lawyer would appear herself or arrange other counsel, claiming the lawyer was not qualified to appear in the Court of Appeal.

While the lawyer had indicated she would seek more experienced counsel to appear, she did not tell the client until the day before the hearing that she would appear herself.

Following the hearing, the lawyer failed to update the client on what had happened in court.

Months later, she wound up her practice, leaving the client without advice, information about future representation or clear handover arrangements.

There was also a delay in the lawyer returning the client’s file, with it not supplied until about six months after the client requested it and only after a complaint was lodged with the Law Society.

The committee found the lawyer had been qualified to appear in the Court of Appeal and could not be criticised for being open about the extent of her experience.

However, it concluded she failed to keep her client adequately informed.

It said she should have provided more regular updates about both the hearing date and representation arrangements.

The committee described the lawyer’s lack of communication following the hearing as “radio silence”.

It found the lawyer had ongoing communication obligations even after she stopped practising on her own account and should have at least responded to the client’s requests and provided a list of lawyers who might be able to assist.

According to the decision, the failures left the client “unsupported and vulnerable” and missing the opportunity to take any further action in response to the Court of Appeal judgment.

The lawyer acknowledged the delays and said she had been unwell and experiencing mental health difficulties.

The committee accepted her circumstances but said lawyers must ensure personal issues do not expose clients to risk or disadvantage.

She was ordered to pay compensation of $2000.

Months without a response

In the second case, the lawyer was acting for a client involved in a property dispute.

After advising the client to obtain specialist reports and evidence, he stopped progressing the matter.

The committee found no meaningful work was completed for several months and multiple emails from the client went unanswered.

An expert report, which the lawyer identified as important to advancing the case, was sent to him for review, but he did not review it or inform the client there would be delays.

The committee found he had failed to act in a timely manner and keep his client informed.

The lawyer later explained that a family member had died unexpectedly and that he had significant family obligations.

However, the committee found his lack of communication and progress on the file had begun months before the death.

It nevertheless accepted that the death gave him good cause to terminate the retainer and found he had provided reasonable notice.

However, it determined he had not done enough to help the client find replacement counsel, finding his suggestion that the client approach firms with construction law expertise or seek legal aid did not amount to reasonable assistance.

He was fined $1000.

Tara Shaskey is an assistant editor and reporter for the Open Justice team. She joined NZME in 2022 and has worked as a journalist since 2014.

Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you

Live
Listen on iHeartRadio
Currently On Air
Listen on iHeartRadio