Perspective with Heather du Plessis-Allan: I don't have a problem with us changing the age of consent
So, the UK Government is considering changing the age of consent after the David Walliams and Russell Brand cases. What they're considering is a staggered age of consent. Basically, it would remain 16 for their peer group, meaning other 16 and 17 year olds, but rise to, say, 18 for older adults.
In practice, a 16 or 17 year old would still be legally allowed to engage in a consensual relationship with another 16 or 17-year-old, but they would be off-limits to much older adults. So, let's say a 40-year-old. For that 40-year-old, the age of consent would effectively be 18.
As a result of that proposal now being discussed, at least according to a minister in the UK, there are calls for us to do the same thing here.
Broadly, I don't have a problem with this. I think most of us are uncomfortable with the idea of 16-year-old Mia Latta having a relationship with 30-year-old Russell Brand, which is exactly what happened.
But there are a couple of pieces of context that I think we need to bear in mind during this discussion.
The first is that if I had to choose where to put my energy in this space, it would be into strengthening the punishment for the worst of what Brand and Walliams are accused of doing. In Brand's case, it was rape. That is the ugliest sexual crime that can be committed.
Now, he got a decent lag for all of that. He received 10 and a half years. But we have cases in New Zealand where we do not punish rape properly. There was a case recently, and you may recall it, involving a boy who raped four girls and sexually assaulted another. He received only nine months' home detention.
Putting rapists away for longer would be a priority for me. Although I do acknowledge that we can do both if we want to.
Second, I would urge us to bear in mind, when and if we have this debate, that Western liberal democracies are becoming increasingly puritanical.
The days of the sexual revolution are well and truly over. We are very much back in people's bedrooms, making moral judgements. Just last week, Andy Byron essentially lost his job over an affair with a staff member. Sexual jokes in the workplace can lead to personal grievance cases. We are charging full noise back towards the Victorian era.
Now, that doesn't mean we shouldn't change the age of consent. We absolutely can, if that's something we agree should happen. But if we do it, let's do it because we genuinely believe it is necessary and workable, not simply because we feel like becoming a little more moralistic.
LISTEN ABOVE
Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you