Kerre Woodham: A staggered age of consent doesn't address the real issues
We touched on this a bit yesterday morning, the problematic issue of what consent looks like when there's a power imbalance between two people. You might have a teacher decades older than her pupil, think Brigitte and Emmanuel Macron. Surely the role she has in her pupil's life is that of mentor and authority figure, not lover. And yet here they are, the President and First Lady of France together for many, many years, and Brigitte Macron is living in the presidential palace, not in a jail cell.
The UK government is investigating a law change that would make sex between a much older adult and a teenager between 16 and 18 illegal. Close the Consent Gap is proposing that 16 year olds would not be able to have a sexual relationship with anyone older than 19 and that someone aged 17 would be prohibited from a relationship with anyone older than 20. So they're seeing "much older" as three years. I don't think you can make laws as restrictive as that.
There are some very, very young 16 year olds and there are some worldly wise 16 year olds. If teenagers are working and paying tax at 17, most of them will be drinking by then, even if they're not allowed to buy booze by law. Many of them will be living away from home, not as many as there used to be, given the way of people don't go flatting anymore when they leave school, but many will be working, have their own jobs. Surely they're old enough to choose who they want to sleep with. Well, that's not the problem, sleeping with them, it's having sex with them I suppose, isn't it? Surely they're old enough to choose who they have sex with.
Again, some young people are vulnerable, but not all. Some adults are predatory, but not all. Criminal behaviour should be punished, and I absolutely believe that Russell Brand should be in prison when consent is withdrawn, as in some of his cases, and when consent is never given in the first place, in other of his cases, you're a criminal. Criminal behaviour is the issue here, not relationships where there are age differences. And that knee jerk response of close the consent gap is, is not addressing the issue of criminal, entitled behaviour. Abuse of power and authority is bad, relationships between consenting adults is not.
It's really tricky trying to police human behaviour and there are no absolutes. When you look at the whole load of British "entertainers" who have behaved appallingly and who have been enabled to get away with it, Jimmy Savile, Rolf Harris, Gary Glitter, Chris Denning, Fred Talbot, Russell Brand, and many, many more who have all been convicted —or in the case of Savile posthumously exposed— as predators and abusers of young girls and boys. Introducing a law preventing a sexual relationship between a 17 year old and a 20 year old is not going to help those young people who fall prey to criminal predators. Surely it's teaching young people to listen to their spidey senses. If they feel something is wrong, it is. Step away, back away, do not do it.
And I remember working on the cricket years ago when I was about 19/20 and having the twelfth man being sent round to organise a date with Viv Richards. My spidey senses said if somebody's going to send the twelfth man over to jack up the date, probably not a good idea. I was still extremely naive then, but you know enough to know if the roadie's coming over to say the lead singer would like to see you, if the twelfth man's coming over to say the master would like to see you, you listen to your spidey senses. But not everybody has them, or else they've been beaten out of them. Vulnerable people are going to be vulnerable whether they're 12, 16, 25, but I find it very hard to believe that a 17 year old and a 21 year old could be considered to be having an illegal, unbalanced, predatory relationship. That is not going to be the case. I think the British are trying to fix a major, glaring flaw in their entertainment industry by this knee jerk response, which is not addressing the real issue.
Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you