ZB ZB
Election 2026
Sport
Live now
Start time
Playing for
End time
Listen live
Listen to Newstalk ZB
Up next
Listen live on
ZB

Kerre Woodham: I don't understand some of the overhang complaints

Author
Kerre Woodham ,
Publish Date
Wed, 18 Nov 2026, 1:35pm
The Podcast on iHeartRadio
Photo \ Getty Images

A group of 45 academics and constitutional experts has written an open letter calling for changes to the MMP electoral system to avoid undemocratic elections going into the future. The 11 seat overhang, which initial results are giving us before final votes are counted, is not what most voters of any side surely wants to see. 

According to Andrew Geddis, the four seat overhang for Te Pāti Māori was the result of a deliberate campaign to expand its influence and try to engineer a left block win. National's seven seat overhang, he says, was more an organic result of the party continuing to do well in electorates while the party vote fell away. And we know where a significant number of former National voters went – they went to ACT, they went to New Zealand First, and a few went to The Opportunity Party.  

The academics and the experts are coming at the overhang situation as being unfair. Andrew Geddis says the overhang could deliver a result where you have three parties that have a majority of seats in the house but have received fewer votes across the country than the other four. And he says one of the reasons people were keen on shifting to MMP was that in the past, First Past the Post delivered a government that had less votes than Labour.  Labour might have earned more votes across the country, National had more seats, therefore they were the Government. But that's not the case here. Preliminary results show the country gave 50.36% of the vote to the parties of the Government —National, ACT, and New Zealand First— versus 43.63% of the vote to the Opposition —Labour, Greens, and Te Pāti Māori— and 6.0% to The Opportunity Party.   

At the moment, you could argue that it is fair. There are more voters, by a small margin, who want to see the Government return than want to see the parties of the left take the government seats. The academics point out it was a 6% drop for the right from 2023 when they won 56% of the vote. So it was a drop. There was dissatisfaction. Opportunity came along bright and shiny and new and new ideas and people thought, "Yes please, give me some of that," and voters went away from the two main parties, not just National, but Labour. The balance could change once the special votes are counted and the finals will be tallied in a few weeks.  

Even with TOP taken into account though, even if you put TOP in there, it's still a narrow win to National. So why is there grizzling from the academics? If they were concerned about the overhang situation full stop, I'd be more inclined to listen to them. I don't want to pay for 11 extra MPs with all their accommodation allowances and their flights up and down the country and their wages and their extra super that we top up. I'm really not of a mind to do that because I don't think we are being served well by a number of our politicians. There are some there who work like Trojans, who do an amazing job on behalf of the country, but there are some there who would not know their arse from their elbow. And with 11 more, you can bet your bottom dollar that while we might get some hard workers, we'll also get people who have no idea what they're doing.  

As it stands, it's a narrow win to the right block parties, even with TOP taken into account. It's going to take quite a bit from the specials, which traditionally go left. Even then, it's not an egregious example of disproportionality. It's not like you've got 60% of the vote going to Labour and yet they still cannot form a government, or 60% go to the left block and they still can't form a government because of the electorate seats.  

I'd be more inclined to think that this kind of open letter is not going to restore confidence in the electoral system, but it's going to detract from confidence in academics and experts who look like they're just being poor sports. I don't really understand why they are so concerned about unfairness, disproportionality, when at the moment it's nothing like '78 or '81. But there have been times, in this case there were votes for other parties that were simply discarded. Other minor parties back before we had MMP might have got 6%, 5%, 8% of the vote and they were completely and utterly disregarded. We're fairer now than we were under First Past the Post in terms of representation. And if the Government does get back in, they will have 1% more of the votes along with more electorate seats.  

Why now? Why send the letter out now? It seems very odd. I don't want to see more MPs in Parliament, that's why I'd like the overhang got rid of. They're saying it's because MMP's not working the way it was supposed to. Well, yeah. If you can play the system the way Te Pāti Māori did, the way some former National supporters wanted you to do, like Harry Mowbray, that's the way it works. If you vote for a right block party like ACT because you don't think National's going hard enough, that's the way MMP works. So what, they want to do away with the entire system or just tweak it so that Labour wins next time round? Because that's what it's looking like. 

Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you

Live
Listen on iHeartRadio
Currently On Air
Listen on iHeartRadio