ZB ZB
Election 2026
Sport
Live now
Start time
Playing for
End time
Listen live
Listen to Newstalk ZB
Up next
Listen live on
ZB

Mike's Minute: Is ACC affordable?

Author
Mike Hosking,
Publish Date
Sat, 21 Nov 2026, 8:52am
The Podcast on iHeartRadio
Photo / File

Is it a fair question to ask whether ACC is affordable if we can quite happily ask the question, over and over again, whether Superannuation is affordable? 

The equations appear the same; more people are getting old, therefore the bill goes up. 

More people are injuring themselves therefore the bill goes up. 

To be fair it's a different sized bill, but the same calculations and source apply i.e. demand and paid for by tax or an income-related levy. 

I ask this after reading the stat that gardening injuries come into ACC at 200 a day and cost $120 million a year. That struck me as absurd. 

In a no faults system the unhinged behaviour of us all is captured, and as anyone who follows the ACC story knows, the bill is beyond its capacity to pay in the sense liabilities are through the roof to the extent the Government refers to their surplus/deficit scenario as OBEGAL and OBEGAL X, the latter being without ACC. 

It's an accounting trick Nicola Willis has run with to try and hide the cold, hard truth ACC is massive fiscal drain and the only way to cover it is to bump the fees up. 

I pay about $3,500 a year for basically sitting in a chair and running a radio show. I have never claimed ACC and I've been working for 45 years. I've not paid $3,500 a year the whole time, but you get the point. 

The gardeners are sucking up my fees. 

If we can't afford rich, old people, which seems to be the inference when you ask "if you're working at 67 why are we paying Super?" or "if you're working at 71 and a millionaire why are we handing out money we can't afford?", if that is a discussion, why isn't ACC in the same category? 

We could do it either through income, or means testing, or more realistically as limitation on what it covers. 

Does slicing your finger with pruning shears need to be covered? Does being an idiot on an e-scooter need to be covered? Are there claims where absurdity trumps the cost? 

A multibillion dollar, no-faults system was always going to end up where it is – on the precipice of a fiscal cliff. 

And $120 million from gardeners, ironically, isn't the worst of it. 

Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you

Live
Listen on iHeartRadio
Currently On Air
Listen on iHeartRadio