ZB ZB
Election 2026
Sport
Live now
Start time
Playing for
End time
Listen live
Listen to Newstalk ZB
Up next
Listen live on
ZB

Francesca Rudkin: Here's the bigger problem impacting sandpapergate

Author
Francesca Rudkin,
Publish Date
Sun, 22 Nov 2026, 9:51am
The Podcast on iHeartRadio

There’s been a lot going on this week, but only one story has truly captivated me - Sandpapergate.

I know, the Aussie cricket team’s 2018 cheating scandal has nothing to do with us here in NZ. They weren’t playing a Kiwi team when they got caught caressing a test ball with sandpaper. And as far as we and everyone else knew, the culprits had been caught, tried, sentenced and paid the price for their cheating.  

So why is this story so compelling? Well, it’s about the integrity of Cricket Australia and many of Australia’s top sports people. But what’s most fascinating is that despite numerous attempts to put this sad chapter in test cricket to rest - it just won’t die.  

It’s starting to look like three men were thrown under the bus by team mates who didn’t have the balls - sorry for the pun - to speak up at the time and say ‘this isn’t right’, instead letting them bear the brunt of the country’s cricketing shame.    

There is an old saying in sport, what happens in the dressing room stays in the dressing room. Well, apparently not forever. And Australian cricket is discovering that some secrets have a nasty habit of developing a life of their own.

For those needing a reminder, Cameron Bancroft was caught on television using sandpaper to rough up a cricket ball during a test in South Africa, helping Australia generate reverse swing. In the aftermath, captain Steve Smith, vice-captain David Warner and Bancroft were suspended. They took the fall, tearful apologies were delivered, and Cricket Australia declared its house cleaning complete.

Except perhaps it wasn't.

Former Australian batsman Usman Khawaja in his autobiography has now suggested the entire team, himself included, knew what was happening. Bancroft has subsequently come out and gone further, claiming every player, knew about the use of sandpaper, and that important details were withheld. David Warner has backed him up. Current Australian test captain and 2018 team member Pat Cummins, meanwhile, vehemently denies knowing sandpaper was being used.

So who is telling the truth?

And perhaps the more uncomfortable question: if more people knew why did they allow just three players to carry the can? Was Cricket Australia so desperate to contain the damage to its reputation that it simply didn't want to dig too deeply? These are questions which now need to be answered.    

Imagine being Bancroft. You're caught on camera, humiliated, suspended and branded a cheat, while other team members who you think understood what was happening ducked their heads and have continued their careers largely untouched.  

How do you live with that? Well now we know - not well. Bancroft described the eight-year aftermath of the "Sandpapergate" scandal as carrying an unsustainable weight that destroyed his international career and left him feeling "angry, betrayed and alone."  

And how do his teammates deal with knowing someone else paid the price? That a young man cheated and participated in a cover up, all in the name of wanting to 'fit into' the Australian team. As far as motivations go, this is damning of the team culture.  

Pat Cummins insisted in a 68 minute press conference late last week that he knew nothing about sandpaper being taken onto the field. He is entitled to defend himself. But as more voices emerge his position faces an increasingly uncomfortable credibility test. Being thought of as a cheat is damaging. Being considered a liar can be just as hard to recover from.

Cricket Australia's proposed players' forum, rather than a fresh investigation, just isn’t enough. What is needed now is what should have happened in 2018, an independent, full-blown inquiry involving everyone on the 2018 tour. Pat Cummings should step aside from his captaincy until this is complete. If they don’t do this, this saga is only going to limp on, while the whole team remains under a cloud.  

This is bigger than ball tampering, and that’s why it’s so compelling. It's about honesty, accountability, leadership and whether cricket's much-vaunted spirit means anything when reputations and careers are at stake. It’s also about decision making under pressure, and the extent people will go to win and to protect their ‘truth’.  

You can’t help but think Australia has tried to bury SandpaperGate. It seems the sandpaper was never the problem. The silence was. 

LISTEN ABOVE

Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you

Live
Listen on iHeartRadio
Currently On Air
Listen on iHeartRadio