'We're sorry': Air NZ accused of misleading passengers about compensation rights
The Commerce Commission will file charges against Air New Zealand for breaches of the Fair Trading Act, alleging the airline misled customers.
The airline has responded, offering its apology to customers, but said it was disappointed legal action was being pursued.
The commission alleges the airline misled passengers about their rights to compensation when flights were disrupted for reasons within the airline’s control, issuing statements not in line with the law.
These included statements that compensation was strictly capped at amounts lower than the statutory limits, and statements limiting Air NZ’s liability for certain types of reimbursements.
The commission believes Air NZ has probably been making these misleading statements about consumers’ rights since January 2024.
Commerce Commission deputy chairwoman Anne Callinan said the statements led some passengers to assume incorrectly that they were not entitled to compensation, and that Air NZ rejected legitimate reimbursement claims.
“Ultimately, we believe passengers missed out on money they were entitled to under the law.
“New Zealand’s Civil Aviation Act is clear that airlines have a responsibility to reimburse domestic passengers for losses caused by cancellations or delays that are within the airline’s control, such as staffing or mechanical issues.”
In such circumstances, consumers are entitled to reimbursement for reasonable costs caused by the delay, which may include meals, accommodation and other costs involved in reaching their destination, up to 10 times the cost of the ticket.
Callinan said the Montreal Convention gave consumers rights when travelling internationally, entitling them to the reimbursement of costs, up to convention limits, arising from delays and cancellations.
That was unless the airline did all it reasonably could do to prevent the disruption.
“We expect a big business like Air New Zealand to take its legal obligations seriously and ensure consumers receive all compensation they are entitled to.
“In the past five years, consumers have frequently raised concerns about Air New Zealand. We will not hesitate to act where we believe businesses have not honoured consumers’ legal entitlements or misled consumers about their rights.”
The commission will file charges in the Auckland District Court.
The Travel Agent’s Association of NZ (TAANZ) said the commission’s announcement reinforced its concerns about consumers’ understanding of their rights when air travel is disrupted.
“Many travellers simply aren’t aware of what they are entitled to when flights are delayed or cancelled, or what costs they may be able to claim back. Even when those rights exist, knowing where to turn and how to navigate the process isn’t always straightforward,” the association said.
“TAANZ has been calling on the Government to provide greater clarity around airlines’ obligations and ensure passengers receive clear, consistent information about their rights.
“Consumers should be able to understand what they are entitled to and have confidence that the information they receive from airlines reflects those rights.”
Air New Zealand responds
Air New Zealand chief customer and digital officer Jeremy O’Brien said customers were at the heart of its business.
“We take their experience with us incredibly seriously, including when it comes to managing issues and complaints. We have approached the Commerce Commission’s investigation in good faith and with a genuine commitment to our customers,” O’Brien said.
“The investigation raised concerns about a small number of cases where our communications weren’t as clear as they could have been, or where our compensation policies weren’t applied as intended. We acknowledge that we didn’t get it right for those customers, and we’re sorry.”
O’Brien said as part of the airline’s response it undertook a voluntary review of more than 62,000 claims relating to disruptions within its control, and identified less than 1% of cases where mistakes were made.
He said the airline proactively contacted those customers and “put things right”.
“Our review found that the mistakes made weren’t intentional or systemic. We also quickly reinforced our guidance and training to ensure there is a clear understanding of compensation policies, and that we communicate customers’ entitlements clearly and consistently.
“Over the same period, Air New Zealand carried nearly 45 million passengers. While we’re disappointed the Commission has chosen to start court proceedings given the actions we have already taken, we respect its role and will continue to co-operate throughout the process.”
Tom Raynel is a multimedia business journalist for the Herald, covering small business, retail and tourism.
Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you