Govt's pay equity changes breached Bill of Rights, High Court rules
The High Court has found that the Government’s pay equity overhaul, which made it tougher for women to make claims and cancelled those already underway, breached the Bill of Rights Act.
In a decision released today, Justice Paul Radich found the coalition Government’s Equal Pay Amendment Act 2025, which was passed under urgency, was inconsistent with the right to be free from discrimination on the ground of sex.
A range of unions representing teachers, nurses, public servants, and other educators had brought the case against the act to court.
Justice Radich said he found no tangible evidence to support the Government’s claims that the previous pay equity system was not working, but rather that the main driver of the reforms was to save money, which could have been done with less discriminatory measures.
Today’s finding does not automatically invalidate or strike down the law.
Public Service Association national secretary Fleur Fitzsimons called it a “ground-breaking historic decision” but said the fight was not over.
“Today the court has confirmed what women knew all along, pay equity is a fundamental right and must be upheld,” Fitzsimons said.
“The next Government must now do the right thing by women and restore real pay equity legislation, and the pay equity claims as a priority,” she said.

Workplace Relations and Safety Minister Brooke van Velden led reforms to cancel pay equity bids and make it tougher for future claims. Photo / Mark Mitchell
In the judgment, Justice Radich also said that while the Government claimed the decision was about making a more effective pay equity regime, government papers showed it was clear there was “more to the purpose than that”.
- Controversial pay equity overhaul: Govt minister ‘surprised’ by rights watchdog pushback
- Calls for political parties to make repealing pay equity changes a ‘bottom line’
- Inside Budget 2025: Confidential docs lift lid on KiwiSaver, $8.5b hole, health funding
- Pay equity: Former National MP Marilyn Waring assembles ‘people’s select committee’
- Pay equity, KiwiSaver and housing: Where the Govt cut $21b
The judgment said the reason for what the Government called a “reset” of the pay equity regime was “strictly financial”.
The judgment said there was “nothing tangible in the relevant materials to support the proposition that the previous system was not working as it should”.
“The documents, viewed as a whole, show that the main driver was fiscal,” the judgment said.
The surprise law change prompted hundreds to take to the streets in protest.
The pay equity regime allowed female-dominated workforces to make claims if they believed their jobs were historically undervalued because of sex-based discrimination.
The new act meant 33 current claims of pay inequity by female-dominated workforces would have to be resubmitted and comply with new, tighter conditions.
It was led by Workplace Relations Minister Brooke van Velden, who said the changes sought to “stamp out sex-based discrimination, in a workable and sustainable way”.
The amendment act drew widespread criticism from unions and the opposition, including Labour leader Chris Hipkins, who accused the Government of “gaslighting all Kiwi women” over what the pay equity reforms would mean for pay.
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon dismissed arguments made against the reforms at the time as “disingenuous” and said there was some “scaremongering going on”.
The changes saved an estimated $12.8 billion over four years, with billions funnelled back into the 2025 Budget.
The Human Rights Commission suggested earlier this year that the changes undermined human rights, something van Velden said she was “surprised” by.
Ethan Manera is a Wellington-based journalist covering Wellington issues, local politics and business in the capital. He can be emailed at ethan.manera@nzme.co.nz.
Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you