ZB ZB
Election 2026
Sport
Live now
Start time
Playing for
End time
Listen live
Listen to Newstalk ZB
Up next
Listen live on
ZB

'Beijing's useful idiot': Wayne Brown cops more flak over pro-China comments

Author
Lane Nichols,
Publish Date
Thu, 19 Nov 2026, 12:23pm
Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown has defended pro-China comments in which he suggested democracy had "had its day". Composite Photo / Herald

A prominent Chinese affairs academic says Auckland’s mayor should remember he holds office due to democracy, “not because Beijing gave him permission”. 

“If he thinks democracy has had its day, then he should step down immediately,” University of Canterbury professor Anne-Marie Brady told the Herald. 

“When an elected leader like Mayor [Wayne] Brown starts echoing the Chinese Communist Party narratives after political tourism in China, you have to ask whether he’s representing his constituents or serving as Beijing’s useful idiot,” she said. 

However, Brown is today doubling down on comments he made following a trip to China in which he praised that country’s growth and economic prosperity, but also lamented the state of New Zealand’s democracy. 

His comments were labelled “ill-judged” and “naïve” by international relations expert Professor Robert Patman, and ridiculed yesterday by United States Ambassador Jared Novelly. 

The mayor defended his position. He questioned who was paying Brady’s wages – “taxpayers or USA?” – and pointed to his own business credentials. 

He also noted a recent poll found “more Kiwis trust China than USA so that USA guy needs to do a bit more work”. 

“Has this international expert [Patman] had businesses overseas? I had my own business activities in China, Europe, North and South America, South Africa and Russia,” Brown said. 

“I’ll bet that makes me much more of an international expert than some dick at a university.” 

‘All that’s missing is his pom-poms’ 

Brown’s colleague, Albany Ward councillor John Watson, yesterday asked what had turned the mayor into a cheerleader for Beijing, telling the Post “all that’s missing is his pom-poms”. 

Watson also questioned whether Brown’s position had been compromised and whether ratepayers should fund trips to China. 

Brown told the Post the suggestion he’d been captured was laughable and xenophobic. 

“China is one of New Zealand’s largest trading partners, and it’s usual for me, as the mayor of our largest city, to visit our sister cities over there.” 

Meanwhile, an interview Brown gave to Chinese media during his trip has surfaced this morning, in which Brown claimed Auckland was pro-China while Wellington was more aligned with USA. 

He also said he was “grinding down” the New Zealand Government to make it easier for Chinese visitors to get visas, but “getting rid of the ones that are a bit awkward”, RNZ reported. 

During a 24-minute CGTN interview, Brown said he had a poor relationship with Wellington. 

“Wellington is probably veered a bit more towards America, but Auckland, the biggest city, is definitely more pro-China. We’ve got 300,000 Chinese there anyhow.” 

He said he had suggested selling New Zealand’s Five Eyes seat to Japan. 

“I can’t see anything in it for us.” 

Jared Novelly is the US Ambassador to New Zealand. Jared Novelly is the US Ambassador to New Zealand. 

Yesterday, Novelly unleashed on the mayor after he praised China’s economic success, criticised New Zealand’s electoral system and suggested democracy had “had its day”. 

“OK Boomer! @MayorWayneBrown,” Novelly wrote on X. 

“I suppose New Zealand government requires a minimum level of intelligence to receive an intelligence briefing; it’s obvious from his statements the mayor hasn’t made the cut. 

“Sure, democracy can be messy, slow, and frustrating. So can Auckland traffic. But no one would recommend getting rid of the traffic lights.” 

Novelly said the US and New Zealand didn’t build two successful democracies by deciding that giving people a say “was too much trouble”. 

“Economic growth matters. So do freedom, accountability, and the right to vote your leaders out. And here’s the best part, mayor. 

“In a democracy, you’re perfectly free to disagree with me. Just as Aucklanders and New Zealanders are free to disagree with you.” 

Patman also criticised Brown’s comments but noted China did have an enviable economic performance, and New Zealand could look to emulate China’s success in the education sector. 

Patman also took a swipe at Novelly, saying it was not becoming for a representative of the Trump Administration to “lecture” New Zealand on the “intricacies of democracy”. 

“His President is having trilateral meetings with a dictator that’s invaded his neighbour, Ukraine”, and was also meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping. 

‘Egotistical fool’ 

Meanwhile, the Auckland Ratepayers’ Alliance is calling on Brown to resign after his “anti-democratic remarks” relating to China and New Zealand’s place in the Five Eyes intelligence partnership. 

Spokesman Jordan Williams said Brown owed his job to Aucklanders having a vote. 

“If he thinks democracy has had its day, he should hand in his resignation. 

“Ratepayers elected him to run Auckland. Instead, he’s picking a diplomatic fight while dismissing the very system that gives Aucklanders a say in how their city is run.“ 

Williams said Auckland deserved a mayor who respected the public’s right to question their leaders, challenge their decisions and vote them out. 

Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown argues Labour and National have overseen 40 years of economic decline. Photo / Cameron Pitney.Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown argues Labour and National have overseen 40 years of economic decline. Photo / Cameron Pitney. 

“Instead, we’ve got an egotistical fool with as little respect for voters as he does ratepayers. 

“The question has to be asked, what precisely is the mayor’s attraction to China? It’s so bizarre. 

“He should do the honourable thing and just go.” 

In response, Brown said: “So Ratepayers’ Alliance are against free speech. The free speech is part of their wardrobe of anger. 

“In Beijing, 600 new businesses start every day and I have to put up with nonsense like this.” 

The mayor also shared messages he had received praising his comments yesterday and agreeing with his stance. 

‘It’s time for something else’ 

Yesterday, Brown said New Zealand had a lot to learn from countries such as China, arguing its economic success should be used as a blueprint for improving New Zealand’s fortunes. 

Brown was also critical of the 2026 election campaign, describing it as “a horror story of dreadful interviews for weeks on end”, and saying New Zealand should heed attempts to “game” the mixed member proportional (MMP) system. 

“Democracy’s had its day. It’s time for something else, really,” he told Stuff. 

Asked on Ryan Bridge TODAY whether New Zealand had become too fixated on private property rights, Brown said he didn’t think it was as simplistic as that. 

“I’m not suggesting a massive change in the way we elect people, but what I am suggesting is that, in the last 40 years, the standard of living and everything and the economy in China has gone up like that. 

“In the last 40 years, Labour and National have presided over a decay of our economy. 

“When I was a young boy, we were in the top five of the economies in the world and we’ve been sliding ever since. 

“And I don’t see any reversal of that. So why wouldn’t you try and copy some place which was going well?” 

Brown said he wasn’t advocating for New Zealand to adopt China’s model by praising how they operated, but rather learn from their success. 

New Zealanders worried about our election results being interfered with were wrong to focus on Chinese external influences when the overhang had been engineered by local interests. 

Lane Nichols is Auckland Desk Editor and a senior journalist for the New Zealand Herald with more than 20 years’ experience in the industry. 

Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you

Live
Listen on iHeartRadio
Currently On Air
Listen on iHeartRadio