Kerre Woodham: Are political editors still worth having?
Linda Clark, one of TVNZ's former political editors, now barrister, has written in the Spinoff of the desperate need for media organisations to retain their political editors. TVNZ has proposed a restructure of its news and current affairs operation that includes disestablishing the political editor role and folding parliamentary press gallery reporters into a more general reporting structure. We here at Newstalk ZB don't have a political editor at the moment, we've been trying to fill the role. In the absence of one though, we can call upon the services of Barry Soper, who has years of institutional, invaluable knowledge.
Linda says the political editor's job is in part to understand how issues, people, and Parliament are connected, because consumers of news want help to know what is important and what is worth their time. Do you, you consumers of news, do you? Do you want somebody there to sift through what's important, what is not? She says you can sort the difference, if you have a good political editor, between news and spin. You can't do that without the experience of gallery reporting, she writes, and covering many, many political events. It's not enough to just be a news reporter. You have to understand politics. You need to have a highly developed bullshit radar and a natural capacity for joining the dots. And that is a special skill.
She has a point. A fearful number of press releases come into our inbox when we have a sitting Parliament, with parties pushing stories that flatter them, or if they're in Opposition, accusing the Government of all sorts of malfeasance. A lot of these stories do need to have context around them. If a party's claiming credit for a successful policy outcome, it gives context if you're able to point out the policy was actually introduced under a previous government, for example. It's a tough job. A bit like the job of the MPs that they're reporting on, it's one that's reasonably well paid, but the hours are dreadful and unorthodox. You have to live in Wellington. You have to be prepared for the vitriol, and kind of embedded, you all become, you all become one and the same.
I suppose it's a bit like being a sports reporter and travelling with the All Blacks. You become part of it, you know things that you won't report on because they're personal stuff, but you know them. It's a really close and intimate relationship. But one where you have to be able to make the hard call to report a story where perhaps you might quite like the individual as a human, but they have failed in their job. And you have to report it and you have to live with it. You have to be prepared for vitriol from those you're reporting on and those you're reporting to, to the reporters who think that you're biased or unfair or stupid or fat or ugly if you're a woman. All of that. You have to be prepared to put your head above the parapets.
Linda puts it really well when she says, when she says in the Spinoff article, you have to read a lot to write a little. To know enough, I mean it's very easy just to report the bureaucratic speak and political speak, but to make it understandable and to be able to put it into words we can all understand, you have to know so much more to be able to write a little. But a political editor's going the way of the beta tapes they used to record their interviews on. I hope not. Personally, I need people with experience and expertise in their craft to help explain what is sometimes a real head scratcher. Like why are they doing this? What on earth's going on? How can this possibly be seen to be a good idea?
Tell me Audrey Young in the Herald is not worth every cent she's paid. Yeah, we are not disestablishing the role at ZB, we're just trying to find the right person for the role and the one who wants to move to Wellington, wants to manage a team of young reporters. You have to have been there, you can't just parachute somebody in. You have to know what you're talking about and you have to know the people you're talking about. But to come back to the salient point I suppose, Linda says consumers of news want help to know what is important and what is worth their time. Political editors know the difference between BS and spin and real news. She says we need to have them in our media organisations. Do you agree?
Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you